Monday, 28 April 2014

What makes a good photograph of the Pennines?

What makes a good photograph of the Pennines?

I was asked this in class. It has made me think and reevaluate my work so far. What does make a good photograph of the pennines? In my opinion it must be truth, to photograph what is there and real. No sunsets, sweeping vistas but reality. Any image will mean something different to each individual, show a person a photograph of a car and dependent on culture, geography and age, each would have a different thought looking at the photograph. "I would like to drive one day" or "I'd rather drive a larger car", "What use have I for the car?" So I need to ensure my photographs have meaning across cultural boundaries as well as land boundaries.

photograph taken by me on the borderline of Lancashire and Yorkshire 27 April 2013.
Although I like this photograph as the sky was pretty amazing on this particular day, it is what I am trying to avoid in my final piece of work. It is too pretty, too mass produced and takes away from the message within the photograph, which is about our need for borders and boundaries as human beings, ownership of what is and never will be ours.

There is a fine line between a picture box perfect photograph of the pennines and the photograph actually having some meaning and context. I want to avoid the calendar or biscuit tin perfect photograph and ensure the viewer sees beyond just a pretty image. Originally the photographs were edited in black and white, which did give the original photographs the atmosphere of desolation, loneliness we associate with the pennines, but too me these photographs were too flat, without tone and depth;  depth is something I really want to show within my images.

Here is a black and white photograph taken by me on the Pennines and edited in Photoshop CC. On line viewed it doesn't look to bad, but as a photograph, flat and 2D it does look quite flat and lifeless. It doesn't to me give definition to the vastness and land which id before us, it has no real quality of depth.
The Pennines to me has immense depth, each tone and hue gives meaning to the moors, brings it alive, yet keeps it atmospheric and foreboding. I mentioned before in an earlier blog about the dept within the film photographs I took of the Pennines and I wanted to recreate this through Photoshop onto my digital photographs. The trouble is when taking these hots over different days, with different weather conditions, matching up the final colour, tone and hues would be difficult.

So to over come my issues I decided to reduce the colours within the photograph, to invariably make a monotone colour image, one which monopolises many of the colours we see on the moors, but reduces the colours which would cause distraction and turn the photograph into something I did not want it to be, calendar perfect.  I chose to use the hues and tonality from the Film photographs I took on the Pentax K1000, I altered only the colours, the rest is as was photographed. No longer do I need to crop or straighten the images as I did when I first took up my camera, composition is finally becoming second nature. i feel this is as a direct result from using film cameras as of late.

Here is my edited version, keeping many of the colours and tones associated with the Pennines, yet feel this image has more depth, it looks more 3D than the black and white copy. Its tones give it greater shadows, it looks more like the place I love and visit regular, the Pennines. The above image is still a perfect photograph and is touching on Picture perfect, commercial image, yet still retaining some originality because of the choice of colour. 
I need to choose which images are best suited to my project. Originally it was the area without a physical boundary, yet the photograph above has the boundary line running right through it for the division of lancashire and Yorkshire, Kirklees, Calderdale and Oldham are all contained within this photograph, yet to the land, their is no such distinction, it was here long before our flase borders and boundaries and will continue to be here long after. Boundaries change, move, have been won and lost, taking with it not only the land but lives also, we have sacrificed so much just to name a piece of earth. So the above images symbolise what is there with no visible boundaries in the image, only invented borderlines. However the more I have visited the area and the more I have photographed the more I have seen, and the more I have questioned what makes a good photograph of the Pennines? What makes the strongest statement? Which gives us a better understanding of our need for ownership? How we spoil or land, ruin our heritage and countryside, erode our earth.

So armed with a different photographic head I decided to go out again (and again) and take more and more photographs of the Pennines, letting the land itself unfold before me and tell me its own story. Here are a few of the photographs the Pennines gave to me:




They are slightly brighter than my original images taken, and I will have to adjust all images until tone and colours, hues and exposure are all similar, but I do feel these are more indicative of what I am trying to say. Each photograph contains, barriers, be it walls, fences, paths, all man made and created by us to say 'This belongs to me, I own this piece of the Pennines', 'KEEP OUT'. You can no longer just walk into any of these photographs and continue, you are stopped at some stage and can walk no further. I particularly like the final image, how the grass ti the from is lush and green, yet the land fenced has died, as if being imprisoned has sapped its life. 

No comments:

Post a Comment